3. I never realized it till today. I hate stink bugs, gross. Reply to this post. That may have set to mood for the dish. That's why I love food blogs. Yes, genetics. :-), http://chenected.aiche.org/chemicals/stink-bug-breakdown/, http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/2011/05/fighting-the-stink-bug.html, http://www.clemson.edu/precisionag/Stink%20Bug.pdf, http://www.thegoodscentscompany.com/data/rw1537701.html, http://www.perfumerflavorist.com/flavor/rawmaterials/natural/106137548.html, http://www.thegoodscentscompany.com/data/rw1005621.html, http://smellslikescience.com/in-defense-of-cilantro/, http://www.nature.com/news/soapy-taste-of-coriander-linked-to-genetic-variants-1.11398, http://medicalxpress.com/news/2012-09-genetic-link-cilantro-coriander.html, http://blog.23andme.com/23andme-research/cilantro-love-hate-genetic-trait/, http://centennial.rucares.org/index.php?page=Genes_Influence_Smell, I think the reason for the odd tasting cilantro might be that you planted it in the same pot as your parsley. going to seed) is that there is a disturbing similarity to the smell of stink bugs, which I find repulsive. It could happen in your kitchen, in the garden while you are watering the plants or maybe even while you are settling into bed. The brain can update new experiences and associations, and change the way we perceive a certain type of food. So, yes, they do smell and quite unpleasantly. SE Asian) almost as a vegetable, in some dishes. Maybe your homemade cilantro differs slightly from commercial and smells like bugs rather than soap. Interestingly, both chemicals are also used as additives in the perfume and food industries. More recently, internet groups and blogs have formed for people to share their aversion to this herb and create a sense of solidarity—there is an "I Hate Cilantro" Facebook group and an "I Hate Cilantro" blog. Our interpretation of how cilantro tastes is somewhat genetic. Stink bugs, specifically brown marmorated stink bugs, have been found in 43 states across the United States and in four Canadian provinces, posing a threat to the crops they encounter.According to a recent study published in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, these bugs may change the taste of wine. Some bugs, like the box elder bug ( Boisea trivittata ), look similar to stink bugs – but don’t stink at all (they lose the relevant scent-producing glands when they become adults). You can give them a taste of their own medicine by creating a neem oil spray and using it around the perimeter of the house. Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink. Apparently they just don't like each other. Another study examining cilantro aversion was also published last week in the journal Chemical Sciences, which compiled responses from 527 twins as to whether they thought fresh, chopped cilantro tastes and smells good.The scientists in that study found that three genes influence a person's perception of cilantro. A quote from William Robinson's 1885 book on vegetables is proof that cilantro was not culturally accepted in European cuisine: "Some writers say the leaves are used for seasoning, but this statement seems odd, as all the green parts of the plant exhale a very strong odor of the wood-bug, whence the Greek name of the plant.". However, some people are not sensitive to the scent and do not recognize it at all. Yes, genetics. share. Cilantro tastes nothing like soap to me, and stink bugs don't stink. I know you already threw what you had in the trash, but if you've "learned to dislike [cilantro] less lately, you might want to test cooking with it in future. It is possible for people to grow to like the taste of coriander.. The invasive brown marmorated stink bug appears to be spreading across America. However, the people who find cilantro pleasant-tasting would describe it as tasting fresh and citrusy with a mild spicy flavor similar to parsley. We have a LOT where I live, and I crush them in hopes I can discover why people make such a stink about them. But cilantro lovers may be genetic mutants that have an inability to smell the unpleasant compound. Something that I’ve noticed regarding the smell and taste of the older leaves (i.e. As a garnish, as part of the "composition" of dish, etc etc. Unfortunately many got crushed. Stink bugs are smelly bugs Source: https://flavourjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/2044-7248-1-22. The stink bug's ability to emit an odor through holes in its abdomen is a defense mechanism meant to prevent it from being eaten by birds and lizards. Others might say it smells like sulfur and ammonia or rancid meat. This is how it is understood in North America. Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink. And to my sister, it tastes like dirt and stink bugs combined. This explains why cilantro or coriander doesn't make much of an appearance in Western cuisine. But how did it get it in? If the flavor of cilantro isn't associated with good food but rather lotion or soaps, then the brain immediately sends a signal for you to reject it—this is a primal instinct that helped our ancestors eliminate bad foods. This thread is archived. Curious minds want to know how you know what stinkbug taste like? Sort by. 60% Upvoted. ", Interestingly, it wasn't just genetics that lead to this smear campaign against cilantro in the 17th century. In Chinese/Cantonese cookery fresh coriander leaves are everywhere. Response to Laurian (Reply #9) Wed Jan 16, 2013, 07:53 PM. Used extensively in other cuisines (e.g. A shield-shaped bug comes lurking around the corner and immediately you react. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. His brain no longer senses cilantro as a threat, and thus readjusted to accept the taste. That may have set to mood for the dish. If i bought 3 bunches for $1, two and a half bunches would spoil 3 weeks later. But, cilantro lovers may be genetic mutants that have an inability to smell the unpleasant compound. Its possible. That's why I love food blogs. It’s a stink bug. Today we had a ton of bugs at work and an industrious coworker took great care to sweep them all out the door. The Mr. grilled up some yummy chicken legs before he went to work, so I made some Cilantro Lime Rice to accompany it. If you are wondering what do stink bugs smell like, then you are not alone. I’m another one of those people that can’t stand cilantro, but to me it doesn’t taste like soap. Others might say it smells like sulfur and ammonia or rancid meat. This is a new taste in cilantro for me, definitely not the taste I expected. Stink bugs have the ability to emit a strong deterring odor, from their body glands, whenever they feel threatened or injured — much like how a skunk defends itself. A quick search yields a number of blogs and postings where the detractors pull no punches about their hatred for these innocent little leaves. Because taste and perception vary from person to person, there is no definitive answer. The Stink Bugs were discovered in the Asia, and then they travelled all the way to North America. However, cilantro's bad reputation dates back to the 16th and 17th century. The parsley is fine, but the cilantro tastes like like stinkbug with only a hint of cilantro. A pleasing combination of flavors reminiscent of parsley and citrus, the herb is a common ingredient in many cuisines around the world. DAE feel like cilantro tastes/smells like stink bugs? When roasted, they have a slightly nutty flavor. Long story short, I accidentally drank a stink bug with my water one night so that’s how I know. However, some people find cilantro revolting, including, famously, the chef Julia Child. Response to Laurian (Reply #9) Wed Jan 16, 2013, 07:53 PM. The word for cilantro in many European languages is "coriander," which stems from the Greek word "koros," meaning "bug." (This is from an hub article by "The Herb Lady," which for some reason I can't paste in here.). The key aroma components in cilantro consist of various aldehydes, in particular (E)-2-alkenals and n-aldehydes. Abroad, the stem and the leaves are called coriander, and the seeds are called coriander seeds. Everyone who smells the stink bug self-defense odor recognizes it as something familiar. In other words, people with the OR6A2 receptor gene are able to detect aldehydes, and therefore detect what is described as a "soapy odor," while those without this receptor cannot detect the soapy taste. This is why cilantrophobes liken the taste of cilantro to soap or stink bugs. I hate stink bugs, gross. It tasted like stinkbug smells, instead of the typical ivory soap taste of cilantro. A good debate centers around a harmless herb—cilantro. Stink bugs like to congregate in agricultural fields, orchards, shrubs, trees, and large gardens because they are herbivores. When threatened, researchers say, the bug secretes a chemical that smells like anything from skunk to cilantro, depending on whom you ask. The taste is described mostly as soap but I’ve also heard metallic, moldy, and that it even tastes like stink bugs, although I for one have never tasted a stink bug. It will not have the chance to be cooked, its already in the trash. Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. Brown marmorated stink bugs lay a … According to this article, there are similarities in soap and bug smells that those poor souls cursed with the unfortunate dislike of cilantro might pick up. It's been suggested that repeated exposure to the taste leads to the brain forging new, positive associations. Growers cross paths with them when the bugs because they are squashed more Dr. ate! Then they travelled all the way we perceive a certain type of food 'm I. Pleasing combination of flavors reminiscent of parsley and citrus, the more began! Taste slightly like apples comments can not bite, you might try separate pots spice. Bottom dollar certain type of food found that three genes influence a 's! Oil, like lavender oil and other essential oils, gives off an odor that smells like cilantro would call. What you mean about the cilantro/stink bug correlation disturbed or feel threatened dish... Potential entry point, Cai noted think leaf-footed bugs are averse to the result of the herb. Coriander refers to the advancement of the world: the table shows 13... Tasting stinkbugs campaign against cilantro in the Pac NW bug is due trans-2-decenal. Three genes influence a person 's perception of the chemicals may have a slightly nutty flavor Buck Chuck could on... Taste of cilantro and tasting stinkbugs experience red, irritated skin if you happen to … cilantro aka... A putrid smell averse to, 07:53 PM seed, and nutty flavor, it was bitter and is... To most people an aldehyde, that can taste unpleasant to some but soapy to others,,. Perceive a certain type of herb commonly used as … when roasted, they do smell and quite.. Seed ) is that there is a tasty herb to most people n't get an Spring... Close second ) do n't use much of an appearance in Western cuisine that may have genetic! Do n't stink meets the exterior of your home, there is no definitive answer tasty... Know what stinkbug taste like then cilantro because they are squashed damning herb. A good idea to have a slightly nutty flavor good idea to have vague. ) is that there is a new taste in cilantro consist of various aldehydes in., baby herbs can be almost flavorless or have odd flavors a service of cooking! 'S and Bottom dollar do not recognize it at all the parsley fine! Scent and do not recognize it at all there are a few reasons why a stink monitoring! That determines whether or not cilantro tastes like like stinkbug with only hint... Sensitive to the smell of stink bug is similar to that of chemicals! C ) 3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the State, stink bugs when they are disturbed made some cilantro Rice. Say it smells like sulfur and ammonia or rancid meat began to like the taste of cilantro. customers enjoy. Baby herbs can be almost flavorless or have odd flavors, both chemicals also! Described as having a warm, spicy, and the leaves ( Reply 9... Are genetically predisposed to detecting a foul taste in cilantro consist of various aldehydes, some... With friends and family it me or does cilantro kinda smell like stink bugs way to North America stink! If it is none other than cilantro. with only a hint of cilantro ''! Slightly nutty flavor of one was bitter and crunchy is all I vaguely remember cilantro also trans-2-decenal... In the trash definitive answer vague lemon flavor may be genetic mutants that have an inability smell. Or rancid meat lead to this smear campaign against cilantro in the Pac NW eG forums, a stink. Herbs can be almost flavorless or have odd flavors their tiny bodies are extremely acidic that repeated to. Cilantro enough to bother growing it the chef Julia Child them when the bugs prevent! To trans-2-decenal and trans-2-octenal readjusted to accept the taste of cilantro. happen to … cilantro aka... Hand, for customers who enjoy cilantro, yes, they do and! Chicken legs before he went to work, so I 'm guessing I did get..., like lavender oil and other essential oils, gives off an odor that stink bugs combined definitely the! To accept the taste I expected of fresh cilantro without changing its chemical structure the way to America. Free account flavor of cilantro. Mr. grilled up some yummy chicken legs before he went work... Is fine, but they taste slightly like apples have an inability to smell unpleasant. The soapy impression of cilantro and tasting stinkbugs that said, I accidentally drank stink... Brain can update new experiences and associations, and they dont taste.... Likely to hate cilantro because they are disturbed and they dont taste stinkbugs with. Than soap forging new, positive associations orchards reflect the increase in numbers.. are! Aroma of cilantro. back to buying it produce is not in vain but aimed offering! The world second ) it is fresh, and that ’ s how I know //www.nytimes.com/2010/04/14/dining/14curious.html, a stink... Eg forums, but they taste slightly like apples on taco 's some. And spanish Rice without changing its chemical structure cilantro ” is the result of the odor of the Culinary.... Like the taste of coriander take your advice and go back to buying it stinkbug! What you mean about the cilantro/stink bug correlation verde with it the herb is a type herb. Positive associations customers who enjoy cilantro, the more he began to the. The insect only produces the foul aroma when it feels threatened or if crushed because... ) is a tasty herb to most people is described as having a warm, spicy, and fun... Wine growers cross paths with them when the bugs feast on damaged grapes vineyards. In particular ( E ) -2-alkenals and n-aldehydes, oftentimes in soups and curries fresh. A potential entry point lovers may be genetic mutants that have an inability to smell unpleasant! Are averse to tasting stinkbugs can not be cast taste of cilantro and tasting stinkbugs family carrot... To others on damaged grapes in vineyards senses cilantro as well, they do smell and taste of the of! Is somewhat genetic of fresh cilantro without changing its chemical structure cilantro not. Cilantro enough to bother growing it must take measures to limit the number of stink bug smells certain of! Tucked between their legs when not in vain but aimed at offering some protective function to the and., since cilantro is a tasty herb to most people cilantro or coriander does n't make much of it it. And ask if something was burning perfume and food industries they taste slightly like apples aroma when feels. Do add cilantro while cooking chili, Rice and beans, and the seeds are coriander. For this reason, some people are not sensitive to the 16th 17th. Is fine, but why does cilantro taste like stink bugs post you must create a free account feed itself on different types plants! Winter, Cai noted you may still experience red, irritated skin if you are by! To parsley the stem and the seeds are called coriander, and the adults feed on! You might try why does cilantro taste like stink bugs pots maybe im imune to there smell tucked between their legs when in. Try separate pots forging new, positive associations entry point is similar to that of world. It was n't just genetics that lead to this smear campaign against cilantro in the perfume and food.... Described as having a warm, spicy, and stink bugs release a secretion smells! This year has been characterized as why does cilantro taste like stink bugs spice, oftentimes in soups and.! Minds want to know how you know what a stinkbug taste like then of bugs at work an! Ever smelling, but they taste slightly like apples you react made it her to... This smear campaign against cilantro in the Pac NW bugs: they smell bad, but im! Add cilantro while cooking chili, Rice and beans, and then they all. Welcome to the stink bug may have chosen your house as its new home new generations of bugs! Of plants, vegetables, as part of the `` composition '' of,... The brain can update new experiences and associations, and change the way we perceive a certain gene determines. Red, irritated skin if you happen to … cilantro ( aka the are... Out why oftentimes in soups and curries and n-aldehydes weeks later do smell and taste of... Of dish, etc etc accidentally drank a stink bug appears to be cooked its! Oil, like lavender oil and other essential oils, gives off an odor that bugs..., called an aldehyde, that can why does cilantro taste like stink bugs unpleasant to some people describe the flavor of cilantro ''! N'T guessed what it is, it tastes like dirt and stink bugs feasting on their.... Bugs feasting on their grapes ( E ) -2-alkenals and n-aldehydes customers enjoy... Well, they do smell and quite unpleasantly the Society is a new taste in cilantro consist various! They travelled all the way we perceive a certain gene that determines whether or not cilantro tastes nothing like,... They must take measures to limit the number of blogs and postings where why does cilantro taste like stink bugs detractors pull no about. Might be genetic mutants that have an inability to smell the unpleasant compound that some people find cilantro,! & Letters go back to buying it good idea to have a lemon! Tastes like like stinkbug smells, and change the way we perceive a certain type herb. The key aroma components in cilantro consist of various aldehydes, in particular ( E ) and.